Can I be sacked for having an accident at work and making a claim?

98 questions have been answered on this subject - ask us your question

Many people worry about their job security after being injured at work or how it will affect relations with their employer, especially if they want to seek compensation. The common concern is that claiming against your employer might result in you being sacked. Or, if not sacked, then cold-shouldered, harassed and effectively forced to resign.

First things first: in most cases, fears like this are totally unfounded. You can’t be fired for an accident that wasn’t your fault, or for making a legitimate compensation claim against your employer for your injuries, and such a claim is unlikely to cause you issues at work.

In short, you should think of a compensation claim as a fair legal process rather than something which could antagonise your employer. We deal with countless cases that are resolved without any ill feeling.

Now let’s cover the situation in more detail.

Table of contents

How your employer should handle accidents at work

By law, UK employers have a duty of care to their staff if they are injured at work. All employers should have a published policy known of by key staff members and put in to place whenever the worst happens.

Good employers will deal with accidents in a professional and effective manner. They will record details of an accident in their accident book, report it to the HSE via RIDDOR if required, and not stand in their employees way should they need to make a claim for compensation. Bad employers will be less helpful, they may try to prevent access to the accident book and be obstructive towards staff who are injured, perhaps even threatening them with the sack.

Most employers will act with integrity in the case of an accident, but some may try to pressure you into signing a form that effectively asks you to accept liability for the incident. Try to avoid doing this (although depending on the situation, a tribunal or court may choose to disregard it in any case).

The government has a number of health and safety guidelines that must be followed and it is an employer’s legal obligation to ensure that these guidelines are implemented. If they haven’t been, then your employer is negligent and you have the right to claim compensation.

I’m worried I’ll be sacked if I make a claim. What are my rights?

Your rights are simple. Your employer is not allowed to fire you for proceeding with a legitimate claim. Remember, all employers are required by law to have insurance in place. Employees sometimes hold back from making a valid claim after an accident, wrongly thinking they’ll be leaving their employers out of pocket. But if you do make a successful claim, any compensation will be paid by the insurance company, rather than your employer.

Apart from keeping your job, you also have other rights if you’ve been injured in a work accident, such as being placed on light duties until you recover. Be aware that there’s a three-year limit associated with workplace-related personal injury claims. These claims can sometimes be time-consuming, so our advice would be to get the ball rolling early. The three years begin from the time of the accident.

One other important point. If you do find yourself in a situation where you’ve been sacked following a legitimate claim – which is thankfully rare – you would then have a further case to claim for unfair dismissal. Employees can only be sacked after an accident for their own gross misconduct, or for being drunk or intoxicated at the time of the incident.

What happens if my claim causes bad relations with my employer?

If you work for a large company with an HR department, the firm may not even be aware that a claim’s taking place. Only if you work for a smaller firm, with no HR personnel, might you be unlucky enough to receive negative treatment – and even then, this would be rare.

The majority of reputable employers will view a valid claim in a rational way, rather than seeing it as personal. The truth is, however, that a minority of small businesses do occasionally take claims badly, and may even retaliate by making things more difficult for their employee. If relations between you and your employer do start to sour, to the point where you’re being harassed and unfairly treated, you may feel you have no option but to resign. In this instance, you could have a case for constructive dismissal.

Our partner firm has a leading employment law team who can give advice on your rights, and on what your employer can and cannot do. If, as a result of making a claim, your employer’s behaviour changes and your working environment becomes toxic, it’s important to seek advice immediately.

For constructive dismissal claims, you need to make a claim within three months of resigning.

How to win your claim and keep your job

To help your work accident claim, there are certain steps you are within your rights to take in order to prove what happened.

Firstly, report the incident to your employer as soon as possible. Try to ensure there’s a written record of the accident, ideally in the accident book, or you can put it in writing to your employer by other means. Never sign a report that is inaccurate – especially if you haven’t had a chance to read it or contribute to it.

Try to take photos of your injuries, and the place where the accident occurred. If you’ve been asked to work in an unsafe location, for example, you’ll need to prove this. Should you be too badly injured to take photos yourself, and it’s feasible to ask someone else to do this, always do so.

That said, it’s worth pointing out that if taking photos proves impossible, there’s no need to panic. It certainly doesn’t mean your claim will fail.

Another important piece of advice is to seek medical attention for your injuries. If you’ve been badly hurt this goes without saying, but if your injuries are genuine yet more subtle – or likely to worsen over time – then medical advice won’t just help you in the short-term, it will also give you further evidence to submit, in the event of a claim.

If negligence can be shown, and if you’ve suffered loss of earnings, been negatively impacted or been unable to work as a result of your injury, then there’s a strong chance your claim will be successful. The amount that’s due to you will depend on various factors, including the nature of the accident, the severity of the injury and the length of time you’ve been affected.

It goes without saying, of course, that you need to be honest throughout the process. If any part of a claim is dishonest or misleading, it could lead to the claimant’s employment being terminated. The risk of criminal prosecution could also come into play.

Any other questions? Feel free to get in touch for a no-obligation consultation.

98 questions have been answered on this subject - ask us your question

Leave a comment or question

Please note we can only deal with claims within the UK legal system. Your question will appear once approved and we'll reply as soon as we can. Your email address will not be published, your name will, so feel free just to use a first name.

Comments & Questions

Read on for questions and advice about claiming...

I was sacked after my first accident at work. In the dismissal letter, the company admit the accident wasnt entirely my fault.
No accident book was filled in after the accident, no back to work after being off with whiplash either.
Other drivers have been involved in more serious accidents at work during my time, and have not been sacked.
Do I have a case for unfair dismissal, as I have had no other disciplinary with the company before this accident?

Ian Morris

With regards to the accident at work, as your employer has stated in writing that it was not entirely your fault there is a possibility that you could make a claim for accident at work compensation that would settle on the basis of shared liability. If you would like to take that further, please contact us and we’ll investigate this further for you.

We cannot advise on employment law matters, but do share work with a specialist employment law Solicitor that we could put you in contact with. If you would like to speak to them, please let us know and we can forward you the details.

Reply

I had an accident at work in 2017. I am a domestic at a council run home, a trolley that had been put in there with 3 wheels on it fell on me wen I went to fill my bucket, injuring my shoulder. I filled a accident form in but my shoulder’s been hurting me since and I have been off work since Christmas with it. Doctor’s certificates said this accident was caused by negligence, very mysterious the manager changed all the trolleys the next day saying they were unsafe. I have been in a lot of pain not sleeping on pain killers, I have been scared to be off work because of trigger points I have had to go to work with this till I can’t work anymore, now they are threatening to end my employment, do I have grounds for a claim?

Ian Morris

You most certainly have grounds for a claim and my initial view is that we would be likely to succeed with a claim for you on the basis of your description of your accident at work.

We would like to speak with you on the telephone to take some further information from you and get one of our specialist accident at work Solicitors to pursue this for you on a No Win No Fee basis.

Reply

Had an accident back in Aug 2016, Just myself and a young temp worker (covering for the supervisor who was on holiday) on the nightshift in a warehouse.
The temp worker drove a forklift placing a load onto the weighing scales (aprrox 300kg inc load, 200x200x10cm) and slowly pushed the side of the scales into the inner side of my right foot compressing and trapping my foot against the wall.
There was no (at the time) stoppers to prevent the scales from moving.
Myself has somewhat changed since this accident and I do feel they have not took the stress I have been going through this past year into consideration.
I have not got a clue where I stand who to go to and feel alone about this. I have been for this past year and thinking to claim has been haunting me.
Can my employer terminate my contract with 12 weeks pay notice or force me into a new role which appears to be out of my league (very demanding)?

Ian Morris

We are not employment lawyers so cannot offer specific advice as to the actions of your employer in terms of their management of your contract and position of employment. However, if you are unfit to work for an extended period an employer does have the right to terminate a position on the basis of ill health. I would strongly recommend that you seek advice from a specialist or contact the Citizens Advice Bureau to discuss that element of your enquiry.

We are though, of the view that you may well have a valid claim for accident at work compensation for the initial injury that has lead to this situation. The lack of an emergency stop button or similar could well indicate that you were exposed to a risk of injury that could otherwise have been avoided or minimised and this may well attach employer negligence and liability in your claim.

We would be very happy to instruct our specialist workplace injury compensation Solicitors to pursue a claim for you against the employer and their insurers with a view to seeking a compensation settlement for the injury to your foot as well as recovering any special damages, such as lost wages and costs.

Of course, if your employer does terminate your position you will be out of pocket as a result, so it may be wise to see if you can negotiate with them to allow you to temporarily move to the office based position, even if it is at the cost of a lower salary as you may well be able to recover the difference if you could succeed with your claim.

Reply

Hi, I worked for a scaffolding company and had been working for them for just over 4 yrs. Around 2-3 yrs ago the boss drop a scaffolding tube on my face and I had to have stitches. At the time my employer told to me go to the Hospital, but pressured me to not tell the Hospital that I worked for him and told me to tell the Doctors that the laceration injury had happened in my own back garden – otherwise he said he would sack me. Due to his pressure, I lied to the Hospital because I really couldn’t afford to lose my job as I had my 1st baby on the way (but noted on the hospital computer system)
So I hadn’t had no training or anything at this point, and they didn’t pay my wages for the time I had off.
Due to these injuries I now have trouble eating because of the location of the laceration and where the tube hit my jaw bone, and the location where it’s stitched. It’s never been right since and I now get awful headaches regularly.

Is their a case?

I also have another possible claim due to an accident working at the same company. Whilst at work my my teeth pretty much smashed out by a scaffold board, due to unsafe loading by the boss. I’m in total agony everyday and my teeth are on the verge of dropping out any minute. My boss has now decided to get rid of me due to his unsafe company. Is there a work compensation claim at all?

Ian Morris

With the first incident, you may well have a valid claim for accident at work compensation, but it really will depend on when the accident happened. You need to contact your GP and ask them to advise you when you had the facial injury because if it happened more than 3-years ago there is nothing you can do. However, if it happened less than 3 years ago we may be able to help.

On the second injury at work, this sounds more recent and if I am right in assuming that it happened within the last 3-years, I think we should definitely try to pursue a claim for accident at work compensation for you. We cannot of course guarantee that we would succeed with your claim but we do guarantee that it will cost you nothing should your claim fail.

The situation that your former employer put you in with regards to pressurising you not to pursue a claim or tell the truth to the Hospital authorities is disgusting and is something you should consider reporting to the Health and Safety executive as it sounds as if that employer needs to be audited and forced to change their ways.

We’d be delighted to assist you with your claims.

Reply

Hi, I was injured at work in January following an assault. Following xrays it turned out I had two fractures, a severed ligament and soft tissue damage. It was explained to me that the ligament was bleeding internally and that the blood calcifies overtime. I am still off work as per doctors advice.
I have been called to a meeting at work and I am worried they will sack me. I only started this role in January and had no induction, training etc. Have I a claim do you think?

Ian Morris

If you were injured as a result of an assault, an attack, then you may well be able to pursue a claim via the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority (CICA) – with which our Solicitors can assist.

It is hard to see how your employer would be responsible for this – unless you work in a role where you deal with people with psychological issues or physical disabilities that make them high risk in terms of violence and were not given adequate training, support, assistance and risk assessments.

Clearly we need to know more to be able to properly advise you.

Regarding your employment rights, that is not an area in which I have expertise, so I cannot advise you. However, if you have only worked for the employer since January, they may well be within their rights to terminate your employment if you are unable to work through ill health. I would suggest that you seek professional advice on that issue from an employment solicitor.

Reply

I had a bad accident on my thumb. I didn’t claim because i was told i would be sacked instantly. It’s been over 3 years. I work with this injury all the time, because it’s manual work and use my hands all the time on machinery and with hand tools it can be very uncomfortable. Can I claim any sort of benefit for working with this injury?

Ian Morris

Unfortunately, there is nothing you can do regarding your injury in terms of any claim for compensation. If the injury gets to the point where you are disabled by it, you may be entitled to disability benefits, but that would not be compensation.

The law only allows a maximum period of 3 years to take action. Your employer has behaved terribly in pressurising you not to claim with the threat of dismissal. They have undermined your legal rights and left you in the situation in which you find yourself.

Reply

Can my boss sack me after having an accident driving his work van which could be my fault?

Ian Morris

You can not be dismissed (legally anyway) simply for being involved in a road traffic accident – whether you are at fault or the innocent party.

You can only be dismissed legally for acts of gross misconduct, continued breaches of company discipline (that have been noted and dealt with by an employer) or through a genuine redundancy process.

Reply
Chat with us for friendly, expert advice 01225 430285