Should You Claim Without a Solicitor & Accept an Insurer’s Offer?

8 questions have been answered on this subject - ask us your question

Whilst we all have the legal right to make an injury compensation claim without the representation of a solicitor, it is usually not advisable to do so. Instructing a specialist personal injury solicitor to represent you on a no win no fee basis ensures that your legal rights are protected and perhaps most importantly, that you receive the maximum possible settlement.

Insurers are likely to deny liability to a client without legal representation and if not, they notoriously make low initial offers to settle a claim. Without the benefit of expert qualified advice, you risk accepting an offer that falls far below the real value that your claim is worth.

During your claim, it is vital to live your life as normally as your injuries permit, while being honest and mindful of how your actions may be perceived. Having the representation of a specialist personal injury solicitor enables you to ensure that you can focus on your recovery and normal life and that you have expert support handling your claim for you.

Key Takeaways:

  • You are likely to get a larger settlement by using a specialist personal injury solicitor.
  • Insurers often use tactics like low offers and delays to minimise payouts.
  • A solicitor will arrange for an independent medical assessment to accurately value your claim.
  • It is crucial to be honest and never exaggerate your injuries or losses, as insurers may use surveillance and will look for any element of wilful dishonesty.
  • Living as normally as possible, within medical advice, helps demonstrate the true impact of your injury.

Free Claim Check – Get Advice Today

Not sure if you’re eligible to make a claim? Our claims expert Ian Morris can review your situation and give you confidential, no-obligation advice.

Our advice is free, and we’re here to support you every step of the way. Drop us a line on 01225 234387 or get in touch via our contact form to learn how we can help you.

The Risks of Claiming Directly With an Insurer

If an insurer has made you an offer to compensate and settle your claim for injury and loss, how will you know if it is fair or whether you are being low-balled by them? The best advice is that you should not accept any offer without first seeking expert legal advice.

Claiming directly without solicitor representation may seem attractive, but doing so comes with significant risks. Insurers are businesses focused on minimising costs, which means their primary goal is to avoid accepting liability and if they do, they will seek to settle your claim for the lowest possible and often below fair amount.

How to Claim By Yourself (The Process)

If you choose to claim without a solicitor, you will deal directly with the responsible party’s insurance company. The process typically involves:

  1. Reporting the accident to the insurer, providing full details of what happened.
  2. Providing details of your injuries and financial losses, including medical bills and proof of lost wages.
  3. Potentially undergoing a medical examination arranged by the insurer’s chosen doctor.
  4. Receiving and considering a settlement offer, which you must then decide to accept or negotiate.

The problem with this approach is knowing what you can claim for and how to value it. Do you know the difference between general and special damages? Do you know how to overcome denials of liability? This is where claimants often run into trouble. Another issue to consider is whether your actions may undermine your claim and make it very difficult for a solicitor to take over the matter and succeed for you.

Common Insurer Tactics to Be Aware Of

Insurance adjusters are experienced negotiators. Understanding their common tactics can help you recognise when you might need professional help:

  • Making Low Initial Offers: Insurers will make a low first offer, hoping you will accept it out of financial need or a desire to get the claims process over with.
  • Delaying the Process: Unnecessary delays in responding or repeatedly asking for the same or more information can wear claimants down, making them more likely to accept a poor offer.
  • Disputing Liability: Even with clear evidence, an insurer may dispute that their client was at fault – all in with the goal of avoiding paying compensation.
  • Undervaluing Long-Term Impacts: Insurers may focus only on your immediate costs, ignoring the future impact of your injuries, such as ongoing treatment needs or loss of earning capacity.

Once you’ve accepted an offer, your claim is settled and closed – forever. You cannot return to the insurers to ask for more money later, even if your injury turns out to be more serious than you first thought.

The Benefits of Using a Specialist Personal Injury Solicitor

Instructing a specialist personal injury solicitor to act for you on a no win no fee basis provides numerous advantages that almost always lead to a better outcome.

Expert Legal Advice and Accurate Claim Valuation

A specialist solicitor understands personal injury law and knows how to prove negligence in your case. A solicitor will accurately value your claim, including future losses, ensuring the right evidence is obtained to support your claim. They will negotiate effectively with experienced insurance adjusters, countering the insurers tactics mentioned earlier to secure the maximum and fair amount of compensation that you are entitled to.

Comprehensive and Independent Medical Evidence

Crucially, a solicitor will arrange for you to see an independent medical expert who specialises in your type of injury. The expert will provide a detailed report summarising your injuries, their long-term impact, and your prognosis for recovery.

This independent medical evidence is far more robust than an assessment arranged by an insurer and is a vital part of the process to ensure you receive a fair settlement that accounts for the pain and discomfort you’ve experienced, your lost income and any future needs or costs you may incur because of the injuries sustained.

Reduced Stress and No Financial Risk

Our specialist solicitors handle will take the stress of handling the claim away from you. They will deal with the pressure of all the insurer’s communication, shielding you from difficult negotiations and protecting you from making mistakes that could harm your claim. With our solicitors no win no fee agreements, there are costs for you to cover and you’ll only contribute to your legal costs if your claim is successful.

But What About the Solicitor’s Fees?

Successful claimants do have to contribute towards the costs of their claim because they cannot compel a defendant to pay 100% of their legal costs. As such, claimants contribute from their settlement if they win. With us, this deduction is capped at a maximum of 25% of any awarded compensation.

It is understandable to think that claiming directly without a solicitor avoids this potential cost, but a specialist solicitor will almost certainly win a settlement that is significantly higher than an insurer’s direct offer. This increase more than covers the success fee you may have deducted from settlement, meaning you still end up with more compensation in your pocket, whilst not having to deal with the stress an insurer may cause during the claims process.

Living Your Life Normally and Honestly During the Claims Process

Whether you are claiming yourself or using a solicitor, it is vital that you try to live your life as normally as possible and as close to the way you lived before your accident, while being completely honest about your condition and following any medical advice you are given.

Personal Injury Surveillance: Are You Being Watched?

Insurance companies may use surveillance to investigate claims and claimants if they suspect any fraudulent activity, especially in high-value cases. Insurers will also monitor claims where no fraud is suspected, simply to try and find ways to undermine a claim. While fraudulent claims are extremely rare, the practice of surveillance can make genuine claimants anxious about their daily activities.

Remember, genuine claimants have nothing to fear. The only people who need to worry are those who dishonestly exaggerate their injuries or losses. An insurer filming you walking your dog or taking your children to the park does not harm your claim if your doctor has advised you to stay active and you have been truthful about your limitations.

The Importance of Honesty and Documenting Your Recovery

Being truthful is of paramount importance. Never exaggerate injury symptoms, but equally, do not downplay the genuine difficulties you face. The aim should be for you to present an accurate picture of the impact your injuries have on your life.

  • Keep a Recovery Diary: Record your daily pain levels, medication, and any difficulties you have with tasks like sleeping, household chores, or work. This provides a clear, contemporaneous record of your recovery journey.
  • Attend All Medical Appointments: Be honest with your doctors about your progress, including both good days and bad days. Your medical records are official evidence for your claim.
  • Take Photos: Regularly photograph any visible injuries to document the healing process.

Balancing Activities with Your Claim

  • Work and Employment: Returning to work, when medically advised, is important. Communicate openly with your employer about any limitations. Consider a phased return or modified duties, and document any difficulties you experience.
  • Social Life and Hobbies: Maintain your social life within your capabilities. Document any pain or discomfort you experience during social activities, such as needing to take frequent breaks.
  • Physical Exercise and Sports: Always follow your doctor’s or physiotherapist’s advice. Engaging in appropriate, approved exercise can aid recovery. Avoid activities that could worsen your condition.

Social Media Considerations

In the world we live in now, claimants should be aware that insurers will monitor your social media profiles and activities. A photo or post can be easily taken out of context. A picture of you smiling at a party could be used to question the severity of your suffering, even if you were in pain and left early. It is wise to increase your privacy settings and avoid posting about your accident, injury, or claim.

A Real-Life Example of Personal Injury Surveillance

A 30-year-old chef and avid sportsman suffered a severely fractured pelvis that required surgery after a car accident. Medical experts agreed that he would never fully recover.

Despite the prognosis, his surgeon advised staying active to prevent further deterioration, specifically advising that he could return to playing tennis, riding his bike, and doing things like cutting the grass. This advice was recorded in his medical records with mobility and fitness known to be beneficial to longer term recovery.

Two years into his claim, the claimant was shocked to discover he was being filmed while playing tennis with his 70-year-old father and whilst mowing his lawn. This occurred even though liability had been admitted. The claimant felt distressed by this surveillance, which seemed to question his integrity despite the clear medical evidence supporting his claim.

By using the medical records and a letter from the surgeon in which they confirmed that they instructed the injured chef to be as active as possible, the chef and his solicitors continued to settle the claim appropriately.

Remember, it’s in everyone’s interest for injured parties to recover as fully as possible. Staying active as possible, following medical advice is sensible and helpful. It is simply the case that you must always be honest about your condition after an accident and how any of your capabilities may be affected.

Unsure About an Insurer’s Offer or How to Proceed?

Dealing with insurers can be stressful, and it’s difficult to know if you’re being fobbed off or offered a fair settlement. Before you accept any offer or proceed with a claim on your own, let our expert team review your case for free.

Our solicitors can tell you what your claim is really worth and they will handle the matter for you on a no win no fee basis, ensuring you get the maximum compensation you deserve with zero stress.

When you make a claim for injury compensation it is important to ensure that you get the maximum settlement available and Direct2Compensation can help with this. Call us on 01225 430285, or if you prefer, .

8 questions have been answered on this subject - ask us your question

Leave a comment or question

Please note we can only deal with claims within the UK legal system. Your question will appear once approved and we'll reply as soon as we can. Your email address will not be published, your name will, so feel free just to use a first name.

Comments & Questions

Read on for questions and advice about claiming...

I tripped on a Council owned footpath, causing facial injuries, lost teeth, a brain haemorrhage and hospitalisation. 2 other firms of solicitors bottled out because the Council (erroneously) denied the claim on the basis that the public footpath was ‘not a highway’. They did however very quickly repair the trip hazards. Should I now pursue a claim on my own?

I sent this comment to Dial-A-Claim:

Hi Jess, I am disappointed that firms like yours and Express Solicitors are so impotent that as soon as a responsible body (Council) deny a claim, based on erroneous legal bases, these firms give up without any sort of fight. I rapidly reaching the conclusion that these firms want to earn their substantial fees in easy to win cases, where the solicitors are not required to undertake a great deal of work or advocacy. In other words: you’ll take the easy money cases but walk away from others. I am considering writing to the Law Society about this scurrilous approach to such cases.

Ian Morris

It is depressing to read that your claim was handled poorly and that you feel badly let down by the claims company and Solicitors you had instructed.

Sadly, when a Solicitor has been instructed on a claim, it makes switching Solicitors very difficult. This is because it becomes cost prohibitive in many cases for a new Solicitor to take on a case. In No Win No Fee matters, a previous Solicitor – even if they have done a poor job – can demand the costs that they incurred in their handling of the claim are met by the new Solicitor if that Solicitor then goes on to succeed with the claim. Sadly, the restricted fees that the Government imposed on Solicitors pursuing personal injury claims through reforms in the last decade simply make it financially unviable for a new Solicitor to take over a case.

With this in mind, the more complaints to the relevant authorities that are made by claimants let down by poor service the better.

Reply

I fractured my ankle on the 21st May 2021 therefore it will be 3 yrs this month as I am still having pain and ongoing issues will you take on this claim?

Ian Morris

Anyone injured in an accident or incident that was not their fault are afforded a period of 3 years within which they can make a claim for personal injury compensation. However, in order for a Solicitor to be able to pursue a claim on a No Win No Fee basis, they generally require a minimum of 6 months of that 3 years to be available. This is because they need time to ensure that they can have all of the relevant evidence in place (time to obtain medical records, time to instruct a medical expert – and receive their report etc) before they would have to risk going to court (which is what you’d have to do on or before the 3 year anniversary to protect the claim from being statute barred). Frustratingly, it is taking longer and longer to obtain medical records and find available experts to report on severity of injury and longer term consequences.

As such, when there is less than 6 months of the 3 years remaining, Solicitors will struggle to see a claim pass the strict risk assessment criteria needed to allow a matter to proceed on a No Win No Fee basis. Frustratingly, this is not because the claim is not strong, but simply that there is no time to get the claim underway in time.

Reply

Child injured defendant admits liability. not been settled Insurer make paltry offer. child over 18 heading toward 21st birthday too sick to deal with case lost abililty to communicate in hospital at . is there any deadline to settle does court the court have any role claimant not in position to reject or accept offer from insurer. Does th court have to sign off the claim?Is making a claim open ended interms of deadline for it to be settled.

Ian Morris

Do you have legal representatives dealing with this/. If so, they should be sorting this for you. If the courts are made aware that the claimant is incapacitated, they should be able to process the settlement and ensure it is paid in to an appropriate trust or account in order to protect it for the individuals use in due course.

Reply

Hello.
I am 36 years old and suffering with an aggressive Dupuytren’s Contracture in the left hand which I had diagnosed February 2018, I believe surgery will be required in the next couple of years. My first employment would require me to sand for upto 7hrs a day every day if the job required it, I worked there from 2000-2016. Is it possible to make a claim against my former employer and represent myself, as I now live/work overseas.

Ian Morris

It is possible to represent yourself in any action – of course, having a specialist act for you may make life easier as they will be able to ensure that any legal rights are upheld and that if there has been negligence, it is established and that it is accounted for.

Reply
Chat with us for friendly, expert advice 01225 430285